Compare AdvantageTMS and Carmine - Apr 2022

Shlomi LaviShlomi Lavi / Apr 27, 2022

We publish unbiased reviews. Our opinions are our own and are not influenced by payments from advertisers. This content is reader-supported, which means if you leave your details with us we may earn a commission. Learn why ITQlick is free .

Bottom Line: Which is Better - AdvantageTMS or Carmine?

AdvantageTMS is more expensive to implement (TCO) than Carmine, and AdvantageTMS is rated higher (85/100) than Carmine (77/100). AdvantageTMS offers users more features (5) than Carmine (0).

Looking for the right Fleet management solution for your business? Buyers are primarily concerned about the real total cost of implementation (TCO), the full list of features, vendor reliability, user reviews, and the pros and cons. In this article we compare between the two software products:

HA Advantage Vs. Carmine

HA Advantage: In partnership with HA Logistics, HA Advantage was established to meet the needs of clients needing more logistics horsepower in their LTL shipping operations, but didn't want to sacrifice operational control or carrier relationships to a third party. HA Advantage is a leading freight-management and financial-reporting company. Leveraging a new...

Carmine: Carmine together with its group companies have over 5,000 satisfied customers globally. We are focusing on the North American market because of the overwhelming need for an effective and simple to use fleet management solution.

Who is more expensive? AdvantageTMS or Carmine?

The real total cost of ownership (TCO) of Fleet management software includes the software license, subscription fees, software training, customizations, hardware (if needed), maintenance and support and other related services. When calculating the TCO, it's important to add all of these ”hidden costs” as well. We prepared a TCO (Total Cost) calculator for AdvantageTMS and Carmine.

AdvantageTMS price Has a free version , On a scale between 1 to 10 AdvantageTMS is rated 8, which is higher than the average cost of Fleet management software. Carmine price starts at $10 per month , When comparing Carmine to its competitors, the software is rated 6 - similar to the average Fleet management software cost.

Bottom line: AdvantageTMS is more expensive than Carmine.

Which software includes more/better features?

We've compared AdvantageTMS Vs. Carmine based on some of the most important and required Fleet management features.

AdvantageTMS: Advanced Shipment Notification, Freight, Document Management, Freight Payment Automation, Shipping Compliance Management.

Carmine: We are still working to collect the list of features for Carmine.

Target customer size

AdvantageTMS is best for small-to-medium size manufacturers, retailers and wholesalers. and Carmine's target customer size include: Small, medium and large size businesses.

AdvantageTMS

ITQlick rating
(4/5)

Has a free version

AdvantageTMS is a web-based freight management system featuring power transportation management system to help you manage your LTL shipping universe. The solution offered by this software is highly scalable, dy...

Categories: Freight, Shipping, Transportation management.

Carmine

ITQlick rating
(4.2/5)

starts at $10 per month

Carmine is a growing cloud-based Fleet management software, it is designed to support small, medium and large size fleet. Carmine received a rating of 4.2 from ITQlick team. The software cost is considered aver...

Categories: Fleet management, Device driver.

Compare specifications

Compare features

AdvantageTMS: 5 Features

Advanced Shipment Notification
Freight
Document Management
Freight Payment Automation
Shipping Compliance Management

Carmine: 0 Features

We are working to collect the information
ITQlick rating ITQlick Rating is based on the software score (below) and aggregated online reviews
ITQlick score ITQlick Score is a 1 to 100, the calculation is based on pricing, and functionality Vs. alternative solutions
Pricing score pricing Score is a 1 to 10 (10 is high cost), based on the TCO (cost of licences, customizations, training, hardware when relevant) Vs. alternative solutions
License pricing license pricing (if provided by the software vendor)
Functionality score
Software review
Compare
AdvantageTMS
ITQlick rating
4/5
Score
85/100
Pricing
9.8/10
License pricing
Has a free version
Functionality
8
Compare
Carmine
ITQlick rating
4.2/5
Score
77/100
Pricing
6.8/10
License pricing
$10 per month
Functionality
3
Fleetio
ITQlick rating
4.8/5
Score
97/100
Pricing
3/10
License pricing
$5 per vehicle
Functionality
12
TranWare
ITQlick rating
3.7/5
Score
92/100
Pricing
6.6/10
License pricing
$29.95 per user/month
Functionality
4
Viamente...
ITQlick rating
4.7/5
Score
91/100
Pricing
5.4/10
License pricing
$29 per vehicle/month
Functionality
6

Auditor - Shlomi Lavi

Website Linkedin profile Facebook Twitter

Shlomi Lavi is an entrepreneur and founder of ITQlick.com. He holds a Bachelor of Science (B.Sc.) in Information Systems Engineering from Ben Gurion University in Israel. Shlomi brings 17 years of global IT and IS management experience as a consultant and implementation expert for small, medium and large-sized (global) companies. Shlomi’s goal is to share the best knowledge and news about information systems so you can make smarter buying decisions for your business.