Compare SmartRecruiters and iCIMS - May 2024

Shlomi LaviShlomi Lavi / May 20, 2024

We publish unbiased reviews. Our opinions are our own and are not influenced by payments from advertisers. This content is reader-supported, which means if you leave your details with us we may earn a commission. Learn why ITQlick is free .

Bottom Line: Which is Better - SmartRecruiters or iCIMS?

Functionality

Both SmartRecruiters and iCIMS offer robust features for applicant tracking, job posting, and candidate management.

SmartRecruiters and iCIMS allow for customized workflows and automation to streamline the recruitment process.

While SmartRecruiters focuses on a user-friendly interface and collaboration tools, iCIMS provides more advanced reporting and analytics capabilities.

SmartRecruiters offers integration with popular job boards and social media platforms, similar to iCIMS.

SmartRecruiters and iCIMS both support mobile applications for on-the-go recruitment tasks.

Pros and Cons

SmartRecruiters Pros: Intuitive interface, strong collaboration features.

SmartRecruiters Cons: Limited reporting capabilities, higher pricing tiers.

iCIMS Pros: Advanced analytics, extensive customization options.

iCIMS Cons: Steeper learning curve, less user-friendly interface compared to SmartRecruiters.

Pricing

SmartRecruiters offers a Standard plan starting at $300 per month for 1 user, $2,000 per month for 10 users, and $18,000 per month for 100 users.

iCIMS pricing starts at $400 per month for 1 user, $3,500 per month for 10 users, and $30,000 per month for 100 users.

User Interface

SmartRecruiters boasts a modern and user-friendly interface for both desktop and mobile users.

iCIMS provides a comprehensive desktop interface but may have a slightly less intuitive mobile experience.

Integration

SmartRecruiters integrates with popular HR tools like BambooHR, LinkedIn, and Slack.

iCIMS offers integrations with ADP, Oracle, and Microsoft Dynamics 365 for seamless data flow.

Scalability

Both SmartRecruiters and iCIMS are scalable solutions designed to accommodate growing businesses with hundreds or even thousands of users.

Security

SmartRecruiters and iCIMS both prioritize data security and hold certifications such as GDPR compliance and SOC 2 Type 2.

SmartRecruiters has been recognized with the ISO 27001 certification for information security management.

Reporting and Analytics

SmartRecruiters users commonly rely on reports such as Time-to-Fill and Sourcing Channel Effectiveness.

iCIMS users frequently utilize reports like Applicant Source and Recruitment Funnel Analysis to optimize their hiring processes.

Support and Maintenance

SmartRecruiters and iCIMS provide SLAs for support response times, with options for chat support and extensive documentation.

Both vendors have robust support systems, but iCIMS may have a slightly more comprehensive SLA compared to SmartRecruiters.

Training and Implementation

Training for SmartRecruiters and iCIMS typically takes a few weeks, with additional costs for personalized onboarding services.

Implementation timelines for both software can vary but generally range from 4 to 12 weeks depending on the organizations size and complexity.

Flexibility

SmartRecruiters and iCIMS are designed to support business growth without imposing strict user limits, allowing for scalability as companies expand.

Data Migration

Both SmartRecruiters and iCIMS offer assistance and tools for data migration, ensuring a smooth transition from legacy systems.

Mobile Access

SmartRecruiters and iCIMS provide mobile applications for recruiters and hiring managers, offering a convenient way to manage tasks on the go.

Cloud-Based or On-Premise

SmartRecruiters and iCIMS are cloud-based solutions, offering the benefits of accessibility, scalability, and automatic updates without the need for on-premise infrastructure.

Vendor Reputation

SmartRecruiters was founded in 2010 and serves over 4,000 customers with around 500,000 users worldwide, known for its innovative approach to recruitment technology.

iCIMS, established in 2000, boasts over 4,000 customers and approximately 25 million users, recognized for its comprehensive talent acquisition solutions.

Industry Certifications

SmartRecruiters has received awards such as the Brandon Hall Group Excellence in Technology and the Stevie Awards for Great Employers.

iCIMS has been honored with accolades like the HR Tech Award for Best Enterprise Talent Acquisition Platform and the Timmy Award for Best Tech Work Culture.

User Reviews

Online sentiment for SmartRecruiters is generally positive, with users praising its ease of use and collaborative features, earning it a score of 85 out of 100.

iCIMS garners favorable feedback for its customization options and advanced analytics, scoring an 82 out of 100 for user satisfaction.

Technical Requirements

SmartRecruiters and iCIMS do not require special server setups and can be managed by a small IT team, typically 1-2 administrators, with cloud-based infrastructure.

Implementation Timeline

On average, the implementation of SmartRecruiters and iCIMS takes 6-10 weeks, with vendor support available for setup and configuration at an additional cost.

Vendor Stability and Compliance

SmartRecruiters and iCIMS are established vendors in the HR tech industry, compliant with data protection regulations and industry standards, ensuring stability and reliability for their customers.

SmartRecruiters

ITQlick rating
(4.2/5)

starts at $100 per user/month

SmartRecruiters is a recruitment management solution. The software provides a unified platform that supports the full recruitment cycle from sourcing, engagement and hiring of the best talent for an organizatio...

Categories: CRM, Self-Service Portal, Human Resources, Applicant Sources & Marketplace.

iCIMS

ITQlick rating
(4.3/5)

starts at $1,700 per month

iCIMS Talent Platform is a cloud-hosted Talent Acquisition and Management Software that lets the users to easily manage the lifecycle of a candidate. It features a TextRecruit module which is a mobile communica...

Categories: Product Lifecycle Management, Applicant Sources & Marketplace, Applicant Tracking, Compensation Management, Employee Recognition.

Compare specifications

Compare features

SmartRecruiters: 6 Features

Applicant Tracking
Mobile Access
Recruiting Management
Reference Checking
Resume Database
Social Networking

iCIMS Talent Platform: 12 Features

Employee Self-Service
HR Management
LMS
Performance Record
Recruiting
Software Customization
Timesheet
Applicant Tracking
Email Integration
Mobile Access
Recruiting Management
Social Networking
ITQlick rating ITQlick Rating is based on the software score (below) and aggregated online reviews
ITQlick score ITQlick Score is a 1 to 100, the calculation is based on pricing, and functionality Vs. alternative solutions
Pricing score pricing Score is a 1 to 10 (10 is high cost), based on the TCO (cost of licences, customizations, training, hardware when relevant) Vs. alternative solutions
License pricing license pricing (if provided by the software vendor)
Functionality score
Software review
Compare
SmartRecruiters
ITQlick rating
4.2/5
Score
92/100
Pricing
5.6/10
License pricing
$100 per user/month
Functionality
15
Compare
iCIMS
ITQlick rating
4.3/5
Score
94/100
Pricing
5.6/10
License pricing
$1,700 per month
Functionality
27
Review
ADP Work...
ITQlick rating
4.3/5
Score
98/100
Pricing
3.6/10
License pricing
$62 per month
Functionality
18
Collage ...
ITQlick rating
4.1/5
Score
97/100
Pricing
2.6/10
License pricing
$7 per user/month
Functionality
22
Bullhorn...
ITQlick rating
4.1/5
Score
97/100
Pricing
2.2/10
License pricing
$99 per user/month
Functionality
18

Auditor - Shlomi Lavi

Website Linkedin profile Facebook Twitter

Shlomi Lavi is an entrepreneur and founder of ITQlick.com. He holds a Bachelor of Science (B.Sc.) in Information Systems Engineering from Ben Gurion University in Israel. Shlomi brings 17 years of global IT and IS management experience as a consultant and implementation expert for small, medium and large-sized (global) companies. Shlomi’s goal is to share the best knowledge and news about information systems so you can make smarter buying decisions for your business.